Thursday, March 29, 2012

Freedom

Last month, we read Freedom by Jonathan Franzen.  Although written as an epic satire, the characters evolved and somehow became more real by the end of the novel.  Most of our members really liked the novel.  The writing was excellent and Franzen's caricatures were well developed.  Some of the members experienced the novel as a bit over written and tedious at times.  Mindy led our discussion and enriched our experience with reviews which had us thinking about aspects of the novel we had not considered.  We were experiencing unusual Spring weather which felt like Summer weather.  We sat out on Tim's screened in porch and enjoyed having Chrysanne back in the country and at the table!




Next month is Milan Kundera's Unbearable Lightness of Being.  We are meeting at Terry's House on April 30th!  Tim is reluctantly on as facilitator...did we mention that he is related to Milan?

Thursday, February 23, 2012

The Sense of an Ending

We met on February 22nd at Mindy's house for an intimate gathering of just four book group members.  Mindy kept bringing out three plates, three forks, three napkins because she kept thinking, "only three tonight!"

We unanimously loved the book!  Previously, we had read Arthur and George in Book Club and some had read Flaubert's Parrot on their own.  We all agreed that The Sense of an Ending far surpassed Barne's other works.  We spent some time talking about the young adolescent boys in the novel, discussing how history was written in with their high school history teacher and then how the main character, Tony writes his own personal history.  New facts are brought to light which cause some dissonance and cause him to revisit his past.  We could all personally relate and shared some liberties we had taken with our own histories and what it felt like when we confronted some facts and feelings we had not considered until they were right in front of us!

We missed Ed, Fred, Chrysanne and Katie!  We are reading Freedom by Jonathan Franzen for next time and we had to change the date to March 19th in order to accommodate Terry's trip.  We had a little discussion about Book Club structure given the fact that Don is no longer here to enlighten us on secondary sources and multiple levels of meaning.  We thought we might try having a person assigned to lead the discussion.  Mindy is on for next time.  See you at Fred's with a back up at Tim's!

Thursday, January 19, 2012

Every Man Dies Alone

 We read Every Man Dies Alone by Hans Fallada this month.  The novel is set in WWII Germany in the Berlin area.  The story is a fictionalized account of the true story of Otto and Elise Hempner who committed acts of civil disobedience by anonymously distributing postcards protesting Nazi acts.  The novel was written by Hans Fallada (pseudonym for Rudolf Wilhelm Friedrich  Ditzen) in 24 days in the last year of his life.  Published in 1947, the novel was not translated into English and published until 2009 when it became a bestseller.  The novel is important because it describes the degradation and helplessness experienced by the German people under the dictatorship of Hitler.

Our discussion revolved around the disturbing violence and helplessness experienced by the characters and the hopefulness about the power of the human spirit to strive for good.  Otto and Anna; Trudell and her husband and Eva Kluge all lose their children and each finds a way to take their grief and anger and rebel against an unjust and unfair government.  Despite their attempts at creating decency, they are meant to feel dirty and criminal.  Otto and Anna and Trudell and her husband sacrifice their lives, while Eva is able to take a young Nazi youth and convert him to a better young man with a bright future.  We think it was Hans Fallada's attempt to find some meaning in all the suffering endured by the Germans during this time.  Although sometimes difficult to read,  we thought Every Man Dies Alone was a good novel to have read.
Otto and Elise Hempner
 Our next book for February 22nd is last year's winner of the Mann Booker Prize, The Sense of an Ending by Julian Barnes.  We hope to be meeting at Fred's house!  Chrysanne will not be able to join us as she will be off on adventure.  Let us know, Fred.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/19/books/julian-barnes-wins-the-man-booker-prize.html

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Dissolution

This month we read Dissolution bu C.J. Sansom.  It is the first of a mystery series with Matthew Shardlake as the prime detective.  The series is set during the reign of King Henry the VIII.  Anne Boleyn has been beheaded and Jane Seymour has just died.  Cromwell is reaching the height of his corruption, dissolving the monastic structure in England.  Profits are used to fill his coffers.   Matthew Shardlake has been sent to a monastery to solve the mystery of one of Cromwell's men who has been beheaded.  As Tim said, "It is a novel with time and place."  Having just read Wolf Hall, the book club members have perhaps had a bit too much of Cromwell, but nonetheless, it was a light read-perfect for the holidays!

Next month, I took my 100th book prerogative to  read Every Man Dies Alone by Hans Fallada. The novel was written in 24 days and published in 1947.  Translation into English was completed in 2009.  My good friend, Tom promises that the book is good and will bring good discussion.  A bit put off by the 544 pages, we are forging forward for the next meeting January  18th at Fred's house with Cindy's as backup.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/01/books/review/Schillinger-t.html?pagewanted=all

Thursday, November 24, 2011

Cat's Tale

We met on November 14th at Tim's house and discussed A Cat's Tale by Michael Ondaatje. There were mixed reviews amongst the members of Book Club.   English Patient had been one of Book Club's top five favorite books and of course the temptation is to think every book will match expectations.  This one was different.  Although the author denies that it is autobiographical, we all had the feel that it was.  A Cat's Tale depicts the microcosm of life on a ship for a young boy and his mates.  The experiences he has on those weeks at sea live with him and effect him for the rest of his life.  Most of us could relate to those poignant memories of experiences growing up that stay with us and influence most of what we feel later in life.   In general, we gave A Cat's Tale favorable reviews!

The next meeting is on December 12th.  We were going to meet at Fred's but, his mother is having a medical procedure and he can't host.  Chrysanne is going to host.  We are reading Dissolution by C.J. Sansom.  Will fill in about our discussion later.

Friday, October 21, 2011

State of Wonder

Manaus Opera House

Our Bookgroup read Ann Patchett's State of Wonder this month.  Pictured above is the Manaus Opera House where Marina and Dr. Swenson finally meet.  The description of Marina's feet walking in heels chasing down Dr. Swenson was something the women in the group could identify with!  Marina cautiously moved her toes from side to side.   Her feet were swollen while she had been sitting and straps of her sandals were now cutting deep into the skin.  While Ed could not identify with the high heels in Manaus, he did point out that this book had an incredible sense of place.  One could just feel that uneasiness of a primitive setting with meandering rivers replete with crawling insects, unbearable heat and a sense of order and law alien to the visitor.

Overall we had mixed reviews.  We all agreed that  this book had the same flavor and feel of previous novels by Patchett: unusual characters, imaginative scenarios and the sense of place.  Some of her metaphors stopped us in our tracts.  Mindy and I both marked this passage about hope: Hope is a horrible thing, you know.  I don't know who decided to package hope as a virtue because it's not.  It's a plague. Hope is like walking around with a fishhook in your mouth and somebody keeps pulling it and pulling it. Everyone agreed that we find that Patchett's novels have not had the most satisfactory endings (or the ones we would have written).  Both Bel Canto and State of Wonder wrap things up a little too neatly for us.  We prefer messy.  We speculated: What if Dr. Swenson had died in childbirth and Marina had had to take up her practice?  Or what if Marina had to come back and report that indeed Anders had died.  And what if Easter had not been given up to his tribe?  All this great discussion while we ate much too much of Louise's incredible spread of chicken curry, salad, and antipasta.

Over dessert...lemon pudding cake with whipped cream and raspberries, fresh fruit and chocolate chip cookies ( I feel I must mention the food since we were expecting Ed to procure the same IGA lasagne he always gets and names appropriately for the book's theme...Amazonian Lasagne, Mexican Lasagne, etc.), we discussed possible  books for next month.  Our newest member, Fred, came through with some pretty interesting titles.  A couple of edgy novels which were eyed cautiously before the group decided upon a previously read author, Michael Ondaatje, The Cat's Table.   Chrysanne texted Kate who gave it a good recommendation.  Fred sent a NY Times Review in case you are interested.  http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/16/books/review/the-cats-table-by-michael-ondaatje-book-review.html?hpw

We missed Katie and Terry and hope to see you next month!


We will  meet next month at Tim's on November 14th.  See you there!

Sunday, September 25, 2011

Old Filth At the Brick House

Katie, thank you for a delightful evening at the Brick House at Shelburne Farms.  Make no mistake, we enjoyed your tour over the the more traditional route!  And I think Edward and Betty would have been quite comfortable at the Brick House.  Betty in her pearls and Edward in his lawyer's attire.  The general consensus was that we liked Old Filth by Jane Gardam.  Katie started book group off with a question which got right to the heart of the matter.  "If you don't experience love as a child, can you ever really love?"  Edward, the main character, certainly struggled with love and relationship throughout, however, he fell in and out of luck in relationships which either caused pain or created unexpected opportunities for him.

Mindy particularly liked the Raj element of Edward and Betty's Empire Orphan life.  The couple never really fit anywhere, traveling about from London to Hong Kong to Dorset.  Edward finally feels at home when he breathes in the warm air of Singapore in the very last scene.  Poor Betty dies by her tulip bed...which brings me to the companion novel by Jane Gardam's The Man in the Wooden Hat which tells the story from Betty's point of view.  Mindy read the novel and wouldn't give a bit of it away.  Chrysanne immediately borrowed it and Ed was going out to get a copy.  Ed, by the way, was relieved he wouldn't have to hide the cover title.  He was tired of explaining that Old Filth stood for Failed in London, try Hong Kong.

Our next novel is Ann Patchett's State of Wonder.  We will meet at Ed's on October 19th.  Here is a link to the NY Times review of our book:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/19/books/review/book-review-state-of-wonder-by-ann-patchett.html